In this saxophone comparison, I put two legends side by side: the 1956 Selmer Mark VI tenor saxophone and the Ishimori Wood Stone “New Vintage” tenor saxophone.
Both instruments represent different eras of craftsmanship — one is the timeless benchmark for professional saxophonists, the other a modern masterpiece inspired by that very legacy.
🎷 Watch the full comparison on YouTube:
👉 Selmer Mark VI vs Ishimori Wood Stone “New Vintage” Tenor Saxophone
Why the Selmer Mark VI is Still the Gold Standard
The Selmer Mark VI (produced from 1954–1974) remains one of the most sought-after saxophones ever made. Its tone is rich, nuanced, and instantly recognisable. Many of the greatest players — from John Coltrane and Sonny Rollins to Stan Getz — made history on a Mark VI.
In this test, I explore:
- How the Mark VI responds across low, mid, and upper registers
- The tonal complexity and natural projection
- How it handles different dynamic levels and articulations
Even after nearly 70 years, the Mark VI continues to define what “great saxophone sound” means.
The Ishimori Wood Stone “New Vintage”: A Modern Classic
The Ishimori Wood Stone “New Vintage” tenor saxophone is built in Tokyo by Ishimori Winds, known for their meticulous approach to saxophone design. It’s a modern horn that pays homage to the Mark VI, aiming to recreate that classic resonance with modern precision.
Key points from the play test:
- Exceptional intonation and balance
- Smooth keywork and consistent response
- A warm, centred tone with plenty of body
It’s easy to see why many professionals are turning to Ishimori as a serious modern alternative to vintage Selmers.
Selmer Mark VI vs Ishimori Wood Stone: Which Comes Out on Top?
This is where things get subjective. The Mark VI feels like history in your hands — expressive, slightly unpredictable, but endlessly inspiring. The Wood Stone feels refined, stable, and reliable — it plays exactly how you expect it to, every time.
If you value character, the Mark VI still reigns supreme.
If you want consistency and a horn that’s gig-ready straight out of the case, the Ishimori Wood Stone earns its place among the best modern saxophones on the market.
Final Thoughts
This isn’t just a comparison of two instruments — it’s a conversation between past and present. Both saxophones have their magic. Which one you prefer depends on your playing style, taste, and what you value most in a horn.
🎬 Watch the full Selmer Mark VI vs Ishimori Wood Stone “New Vintage” video here:
👉 Watch now on YouTube
💬 Which saxophone would you choose — the vintage icon or the new generation built in its image? Share your thoughts in the comments.